8849 Shelby St. Suite A2, Indianapolis,IN
Location
Checking status...
wagner sleep dentist logo

Tooth-Colored Dental Fillings in IndianapolisIN

A healthy smile is one of your greatest assets, and when cavities threaten it, quick action makes all the difference. At Wagner Sleep Dentistry, we provide dental fillings in Indianapolis that restore strength, function, and appearance—all while keeping your comfort a top priority. Whether you’re dealing with tooth sensitivity or a new cavity, our gentle and precise approach ensures you get back to smiling with confidence.

Request an Appointment

What Are Dental Fillings?

Dental fillings are one of the most common treatments in dentistry, designed to repair teeth affected by decay or minor damage. A filling works by sealing the cavity after the decayed portion of the tooth is removed. 

This not only restores normal function but also prevents bacteria from spreading further. At Wagner Sleep Dentistry, our fillings are carefully crafted to look natural and blend seamlessly with the rest of your teeth. Learn more about our full range of dental services.

Types of Fillings Available

Patients today have more choices than ever when it comes to dental fillings. At Wagner Sleep Dentistry, we offer options to suit your needs:

  • Composite (Tooth-Colored) Fillings – The most popular choice, these fillings match the shade of your teeth and are nearly invisible. They bond tightly to the tooth structure, providing both strength and aesthetics.
  • Amalgam Fillings – Durable silver-colored fillings, used less often today but still effective in certain cases.
  • Ceramic/Porcelain Fillings – Highly resistant to staining and ideal for patients seeking natural-looking, long-lasting results.

For cases where a tooth requires more support, we also provide inlays and onlays as a strong, long-lasting alternative.

Why Choose Tooth-Colored Fillings?

More patients are choosing composite fillings over traditional silver options—and for good reason. They are designed to:

  • Blend naturally with your teeth, making them almost impossible to notice.
  • Provide strength and durability for both front and back teeth.
  • Maintain your smile’s aesthetics, even when you laugh or talk.

At Wagner Sleep Dentistry, we focus on restorations that look good and function well, so you don’t have to choose between health and appearance.

Signs You May Need a Filling

Not sure if a filling is necessary? Here are some common signs to look out for:

  • Tooth sensitivity to hot, cold, or sweet foods.
  • Discomfort when chewing or biting down.
  • Visible dark spots or small holes on a tooth.
  • A cracked, chipped, or worn-down tooth.

If you notice these issues, early treatment is key. A simple filling is far less invasive than waiting until you need root canal therapy.

The Filling Procedure at Wagner Sleep Dentistry

Many patients are pleasantly surprised by how quick and comfortable a filling appointment can be. Here’s what you can expect:

  1. Comprehensive Exam – We begin with an exam and imaging to confirm the extent of decay.
  2. Gentle Numbing – Local anesthesia ensures you stay comfortable throughout the procedure.
  3. Decay Removal – The affected part of the tooth is carefully removed.
  4. Filling Placement – A durable, tooth-colored material is placed and shaped.
  5. Bite Adjustment – We make sure your filling feels natural when you bite down.

For patients who feel anxious about dental visits, our sedation dentistry options make the process even easier.

Benefits of Getting a Filling Early 

Cavities won’t heal on their own, which is why getting a filling as soon as possible is so important. Early treatment stops decay from spreading deeper, preserves more of your natural tooth structure, and reduces the chance of needing larger restorations later on. 

It also restores comfort, making it easier to eat and smile without discomfort. With timely care at Wagner Sleep Dentistry, you can prevent complications and keep your smile healthy and strong.

Why Choose Wagner Sleep Dentistry? 

When it comes to dental fillings in Indianapolis, patients choose Wagner Sleep Dentistry for our expertise and patient-focused care. We combine advanced restorative and cosmetic dentistry with a compassionate approach that prioritizes comfort. For anxious patients, our sleep dentistry options make treatment easier and stress-free. Conveniently located near Southport, Homecroft, and Perry Township, we’re proud to provide advanced care in a comfortable setting.

Patient-Focused Care at Wagner Sleep Dentistry 

At Wagner Sleep Dentistry, we believe every patient deserves a comfortable, stress-free dental visit. Whether you’re coming in for dental fillings in Indianapolis, preventive checkups, or advanced care, our friendly team is here to help. 

We welcome new patients and make scheduling easy—our office is open Monday 8–5, Tuesday 9–5, Wednesday 8–4, and Thursday 8–5.

If you’re ready to protect your smile, visit our new patient page, schedule online through our contact page, or give us a call. Don’t wait for a cavity to get worse—book your appointment today and experience gentle, modern care tailored to you.

FAQs

Can tooth-colored fillings be used to replace old silver fillings?

Yes, older amalgam fillings can be safely replaced with tooth-colored options, which bond securely and look more natural.

Do tooth-colored fillings require special care compared to natural teeth?

No—regular brushing, flossing, and checkups are enough. Just avoid habits like chewing ice to keep them strong.

Are tooth-colored fillings suitable for children as well as adults?

Yes, composite fillings are durable and blend naturally, making them a great choice for kids.

How do I know if a small cavity needs a filling or just monitoring?

Yes, composite fillings can repair chips, worn edges, or small gaps for better function and appearance.

What our patients say

  • Nothing but positive things to say about this place! Every staff member I've interacted with is knowledgeable and kind. Going to the dentist no longer makes me anxious. I highly... read more

    Laura Moon Avatar Laura Moon
    August 16, 2024

    I have been going to Dr. Wagner for decades. Her staff is all female, which as a person with a small mouth and jaw, I really appreciate the smaller hands.... read more

    Carol Farrington Avatar Carol Farrington
    September 18, 2025

    Actually, today was one of the best cleanings I have ever had. Would love to have Linda everytime.

    Linda Clark Avatar Linda Clark
    June 24, 2025
  • This is my 4th cleaning day. I have never looked forward to getting dental work done but this is a very professional, friendly efficient practice. Now I look... read more

    Susan Fillmer Avatar Susan Fillmer
    April 30, 2025

    Everything went well.. the staff is so friendly. Susan (the dentist) takes time to explain what all is going in and does not rush you out the door. ... read more

    Pam Stultz Avatar Pam Stultz
    June 10, 2025

    We’re kind and personable yet professional! Took time with me to explain what I needed done.

    Patricia Duncan Avatar Patricia Duncan
    August 12, 2025
  • Jennifer, Dental Hygienist was thorough with my exam and cleaning! Thank You, Jennifer!

    Amber Nugent Avatar Amber Nugent
    September 12, 2025

    Always great to see the beautiful staff at Dr Susan Wagner’s office. Always a pleasant experience when I visit for any procedure. I highly recommend Dr Susan if... read more

    celine masterson Avatar celine masterson
    August 27, 2025

    The kindest group of ladies you’ll ever find from reception to dentist. I hadn’t been to the dentist in about 5 years (due to fear among other things). I finally... read more

    Hayden Phillips Avatar Hayden Phillips
    April 18, 2023

Success stories that speak for themselves