8849 Shelby St #2, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States
Checking hours
Checking hours
SCHEDULE YOUR VISITBOOKSCHEDULE
 
wagner sleep dentist logo

Tooth Extractions in Indianapolis, IN

Wagner Sleep Dentistry provides gentle, precise, and patient-focused tooth extractions in Indianapolis, IN, designed to relieve pain, stop infection, and restore oral health. Our skilled team performs extractions for damaged or decayed teeth that can’t be saved, ensuring your comfort and peace of mind at every step.

Request an Appointment

When a Tooth Extraction May Be Needed

In many cases, saving a natural tooth is the goal—but sometimes removal is the best way to protect your overall dental health. An extraction may be recommended if you have:

  • Extensive tooth decay or infection.
  • A fractured tooth below the gumline.
  • Severe damage from trauma or injury.
  • Overcrowding before orthodontic treatment.

Our dentists evaluate each case carefully and recommend extraction only when necessary. With our advanced techniques and sedation options, the procedure is quick, precise, and virtually painless.

Comfortable Tooth Extractions You Can Trust

At Wagner Sleep Dentistry, patient comfort comes first. Using state-of-the-art imaging and gentle techniques, we plan each extraction precisely to minimize tissue impact and promote faster healing. Our team takes time to explain the procedure, answer questions, and ensure you feel fully informed before treatment begins.

From single-tooth extractions to more complex removals, our approach focuses on precision, comfort, and your long-term oral health.

Sedation Dentistry for a Stress-Free Experience

Dental anxiety is completely normal—and that’s where our sedation dentistry services make a difference. Wagner Sleep Dentistry offers several forms of sedation, including nitrous oxide, oral sedation, and IV sedation, allowing you to remain calm and relaxed throughout your procedure.

As a trusted local provider of sedation-supported tooth extractions in Indianapolis, IN, we personalize each plan based on your comfort level and needs. With our experienced team, even the most nervous patients can feel at ease during treatment.

Wisdom Tooth Extractions: Referred to Trusted Specialists

While our office performs extractions for most teeth, wisdom tooth removals are referred to a trusted local specialist. This ensures you receive expert surgical care when needed.

If your wisdom teeth are impacted or causing discomfort, our team will assess your situation and refer you to a reputable specialist for a safe, smooth extraction experience.

What to Expect During and After Your Extraction

We want every patient to feel confident and prepared. Here’s what to expect during your visit:

  1. Comprehensive Evaluation: A full exam and digital imaging to plan your treatment.
  2. Sedation and Anesthesia Options: A tailored comfort plan to reduce anxiety and pain.
  3. Gentle Extraction: Precise, minimally invasive removal of the affected tooth.
  4. Aftercare Guidance: Step-by-step recovery instructions to support healing.

You may experience minor swelling or tenderness for a few days, which can be managed with proper aftercare. Avoid hard foods and strenuous activity for the first 24–48 hours, and our team will check in to ensure a smooth recovery.

Replacing a Missing Tooth After Extraction

Restoring your smile after extraction is just as important as removing the damaged tooth. Wagner Sleep Dentistry offers advanced replacement solutions such as dental bridges and dentures to restore both function and aesthetics.

Replacing a missing tooth helps prevent bone loss, bite misalignment, and shifting of neighboring teeth. Our team will work closely with you to create a personalized treatment plan that matches your oral health goals and maintains your natural-looking smile.

Why Patients Choose Wagner Sleep Dentistry

Patients throughout Indianapolis trust Wagner Sleep Dentistry for comfortable and precise tooth extractions because we provide:

  • Gentle, patient-centered care for all ages.
  • Expertise in sedation dentistry for stress-free procedures.
  • Modern diagnostic tools and precision techniques.
  • A supportive environment focused on long-term oral health.

We’re committed to ensuring every patient receives care that’s as relaxing as it is effective.

Schedule Your Tooth Extraction in Indianapolis, IN

If you’re experiencing severe tooth decay, damage, or persistent dental pain, timely care can help prevent complications and restore your comfort. Contact Wagner Sleep Dentistry today to schedule your tooth extraction in Indianapolis, IN, and experience compassionate, sedation-supported care tailored to your needs.

Our office is open Monday and Tuesday from 8 AM–5 PM, Wednesday from 8 AM–4 PM, and Thursday from 8 AM–5 PM with flexible scheduling to fit your routine. We’re closed Friday through Sunday as our team prepares for another week of dedicated patient care.We’re dedicated to making every dental visit as smooth, comfortable, and stress-free as possible. Call our office or request your appointment online today to begin your path toward a healthier, pain-free smile.

What our patients say

  • I appreciate the professional service and friendly staff. Always quick to respond to any issues I may have. Highly recommend! Terry T.

    Terry Thompson Avatar Terry Thompson
    June 17, 2025

    Entire team is fabulous! So welcoming and compassionate. Dr W is the BEST!!! Highly skilled at everything she offers!

    Keisa Messer Avatar Keisa Messer
    August 7, 2025

    This is my 4th cleaning day. I have never looked forward to getting dental work done but this is a very professional, friendly efficient practice. Now I look... read more

    Susan Fillmer Avatar Susan Fillmer
    April 30, 2025
  • I love going to this dental office. Dr. Wagner and her staff are very caring. They do a great job and explain the procedures well.

    Amy Studebaker Avatar Amy Studebaker
    June 3, 2025

    Always great to see the beautiful staff at Dr Susan Wagner’s office. Always a pleasant experience when I visit for any procedure. I highly recommend Dr Susan if... read more

    celine masterson Avatar celine masterson
    August 27, 2025

    Well run office. They are very conscientious in helping individuals maintain healthy teeth.

    Roger Kinsey Avatar Roger Kinsey
    June 18, 2025
  • Update 10/8/24: Again I can’t express enough how pleased I am with Dr Wagner and her staff, especially Linda my hygienist! She is thorough and gentle when working on my... read more

    Cyndi Maddox (Cyndi) Avatar Cyndi Maddox (Cyndi)
    October 9, 2024

    Everything went well.. the staff is so friendly. Susan (the dentist) takes time to explain what all is going in and does not rush you out the door. ... read more

    Pam Stultz Avatar Pam Stultz
    June 10, 2025

    Consistently pleased with the kindness I’m met with by the staff and the quality of my routine cleanings

    Lukas Smith Avatar Lukas Smith
    September 16, 2025

Success stories that speak for themselves

Related Articles

How Long Does It Take to Extract a Tooth?

The short answer is that the actual removal of a tooth may take only a few minutes, but the full appointment often…

Read More
Wisdom Tooth Coming In: What It Looks and Feels Like

A wisdom tooth coming in often first changes the look of the very back of the mouth. The gum behind the last…

Read More